Cream stucco house with a clay tile roof, arched window and recessed entry above a sloping garden with an autumn maple.

Forest Hill's Housing Supply Is Decided in a Hearing Room

October 29, 2026

At the corner of Pacheco Street and Marcela Avenue, a planning notice stands on a post next to a mature Japanese maple, on one of the few empty lots left in Forest Hill. The lot is 288 Pacheco. Its owners want to build a five-bedroom, roughly 5,300-square-foot house on it. The city record for that house begins in 2023.

According to the Planning Department, as reported by The San Francisco Standard, the last time a home was built in Forest Hill was 2020. To understand Forest Hill prices, start with that number and with how one corner lot got from a plan to a hearing date.

Three years, one house, about three feet

The city's own file shows how long it takes to add a single detached house inside Forest Hill.

  1. 2023. The project gets its record number, 2023-008594. Per the Standard, the first design called for a home 32 feet tall with no roof deck. A real estate investment fund owned the lot then. Its CEO told the Standard the firm sold after running into neighbor opposition and permitting trouble.
  2. June 8 to July 8, 2026. The 30-day neighborhood notice period runs.
  3. July 8, 2026. The adjacent neighbors file for Discretionary Review. A petition signed by 49 neighbors goes into the record.
  4. August 2026. The owners respond on August 3. City-facilitated mediation follows, and modified plans are dated August 25.
  5. September 10, 2026. At the Planning Commission, the Discretionary Review request is announced as withdrawn before any vote.

The fight over that house was about a few feet, and the arguments were technical. The owners say the design meets the city's 35-foot height limit. The neighbors argued that, measured from a different point, it reaches 43.5 feet. Planning staff had suggested a hipped or gabled roof. The design kept a steep mansard and an attic of about 1,475 square feet that falls a few inches short of counting as a full fourth story.

Inside the district, neighbors win concessions

The leverage comes from where the lot sits. The staff report places 288 Pacheco in the "eligible Forest Hill Historic District." That district's character is set by one- and two-story detached homes. Under the city's Discretionary Review process, commissioners can require changes even when a project already meets the planning code.

Staff found the house code-compliant and consistent with the Residential Design Guidelines. Mediation still produced four changes:

  • Overall height lowered by 3 feet 2 inches through shorter floor-to-ceiling heights
  • Roof deck reduced from 240 to 170 square feet
  • A fire wall facing the neighboring home removed
  • The mansard roof's eave lowered to reduce the building's apparent mass

Staff's recommendation, as printed in the packet:

"Do Not Take DR and Approve as Modified"

The owners told the city the project also complies with the Forest Hill Association's "architectural standards and Agreement."

The concessions are modest, and the cost lands on the calendar. A house first designed in 2023 reached its hearing in September 2026.

On West Portal, the same leverage disappears

The commercial strip below Forest Hill tells a different story. The former Empire Theater site at 85 West Portal Avenue, combined with the neighboring building that holds a Goodwill and a Supercuts, grew this year from a 64-unit, nine-story plan to 172 apartments on 12 floors, with 7,000 square feet of ground-floor retail. Twenty-six of those units are designated below market rate.

SF YIMBY reported on September 1 that the revised filing invokes the city's Family Zoning Plan along with the state laws AB 1287 and SB 423. As of that report, no construction cost or timeline had been shared, so the project remains a proposal on file.

Supervisor Myrna Melgar told the Standard that hours-long listening sessions are no longer required, so she could not make the developers sit down with concerned neighbors. "People have feelings about the way it used to be, where communities could ask for concessions and things," she said. "But that is just no longer the reality that we live in."

288 Pacheco St. 85 West Portal Ave. and neighbor
What's proposed One five-bedroom house 172 apartments, 26 below market rate
Height 35 feet by the owners' measure, 43.5 feet by the neighbors'; reduced 3'2" in mediation 12 stories
Review path Neighborhood notice, Discretionary Review request, city mediation Family Zoning Plan, AB 1287 and SB 423 cited
Neighbor leverage Height, roof deck and roofline changed No required listening sessions
Time on record Filed 2023, hearing September 2026 Revised filing reported September 2026

Where new homes near Forest Hill are actually going

Two proposals near Forest Hill would add multifamily buildings.

West Portal is one example. Another is on Laguna Honda Boulevard. A city notice dated May 5, 2026 moved Mission Housing's proposed project at 250 Laguna Honda Blvd. forward in federal funding review. The plan is 172 affordable units in an eight-story building. The city says its Family Zoning Plan, adopted in December 2025, allows more height and density along major transit and commercial corridors.

Meanwhile, the detached-house count on the hill has barely moved in six years. A vacant corner lot is rare enough to make news, and building one house on it took a three-year file.

What a fixed stock does to a Forest Hill price

That fixed stock is now meeting a tight citywide market. The California Association of Realtors put San Francisco's September 2026 median price for existing detached homes at $2,054,000, up 17.4% from September 2025. Median time on market that month was 21 days.

At the top of the market, the Standard's October 25 report cited brokerage data showing the fewest September listings since 2020 and a 109% year-over-year rise in sales above $5 million. It named Forest Hill as one of the neighborhoods that routinely sees sales above $5 million.

In most neighborhoods, rising prices eventually bring new supply. In Forest Hill, the new supply is mostly apartments on nearby corridors, and those don't compete with a large detached house on a curving street with a lawn. Someone shopping for that kind of house is choosing from what already stands, and new construction won't add many options. A house that needs work is still one of the few ways into the neighborhood.

What the corridor changes for people already on the hill

The apartment building would change the commercial strip below the neighborhood before it adds a single resident. In the Standard's September reporting, West Portal merchants said they expect about two years of construction. Anna Bullard, a West Portal Merchants Association board member and the owner of BookShop West Portal, said anxiety is the overriding feeling among business owners. That includes El Toreador, which has served the street since 1980, Eezy Freezy, West Portal Daily Market, and Mozzarella di Bufala, whose building sits between the two development parcels. Giuseppe Vivacqua, who has owned Spiazzo Ristorante for 30 years, told the paper, "The construction will be a pain, but customers will come anyway. And then the new housing will bring many more people."

An ordinance enacted December 5, 2025 created the Small Business Rezoning Construction Relief Program and Fund. The program offers grants and loans and is run by the Office of Small Business and the Office of Economic and Workforce Development.

Quick questions

What happened to 288 Pacheco in the eligible historic district?

288 Pacheco went from a vacant lot toward approval and was found consistent with the code and design guidelines.

Has the West Portal apartment project been approved?

As of SF YIMBY's September 1 report, the 172-unit revision had been filed, with no construction cost or timeline shared.

This post describes how San Francisco's planning and streamlining rules worked on two recent projects. It is general information, not legal advice, so please confirm how any rule applies to your own property with a land-use attorney or the Planning Department.

If you're thinking about a Forest Hill house that needs a renovation or an addition, Minna Real Estate pairs local pricing knowledge with hands-on project management. Start with a free home valuation.

Begin Your Journey Today

Minna Millare combines San Francisco‑native insight with investment‑savvy strategies, remodeling expertise, and a client-centered approach. Let her guide you step-by-step through California’s dynamic market, ensuring smart decisions and personalized results.